Close
Nobody wants to think about their building project going wrong, but the reality is that problems do happen. Maybe your contractor has disappeared halfway through the job, the work is substandard, or you’re facing massive delays and cost overruns. Whatever the situation, knowing your legal rights and options can save you thousands of pounds and months of stress. I’ve seen too many Manchester homeowners suffer in silence or make rash decisions because they didn’t understand what they were entitled to. This guide will walk you through exactly what happens when things go wrong with a main contractor, what your rights are under UK law, and how to protect yourself and get the project back on track.
Before we get into your rights, it helps to understand what typically goes wrong on building projects in Manchester. Payment disputes are incredibly common. Your contractor might demand money upfront for materials they never order, ask for stage payments when work isn’t finished, or try to charge for extras that were included in the original quote. Quality issues are another big one. The workmanship might be shoddy, materials might not match what was agreed, or the finished result simply doesn’t meet building regulations. Then there are delays. A six month project dragging into nine or twelve months without good reason can cost you thousands in additional rent or mortgage payments.
Sometimes contractors just disappear. They might stop turning up to site, stop returning calls, or vanish completely leaving you with an unfinished project. In worse cases, you might discover that they’ve been cutting corners on safety, haven’t got the right insurance, or are using unlicensed subcontractors. Contract disputes can also arise when there’s disagreement about what was actually agreed, especially if your contract wasn’t clear or detailed enough. Understanding which category your problem falls into helps you work out the best way forward.
The good news is that you have strong legal protections in the UK if you’re a homeowner hiring a contractor for domestic work. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 gives you clear rights that every contractor must follow. Any work must be carried out with reasonable care and skill. This means your contractor can’t just bodge the job or use cowboys who don’t know what they’re doing. The work must be done within a reasonable time unless you agreed a specific deadline in the contract. You shouldn’t be kept waiting indefinitely without good reason.
The price must be reasonable if you didn’t agree a fixed price upfront. Contractors can’t just make up extortionate bills at the end. Any materials supplied must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose, and as described. Your contractor can’t use cheap rubbish when you paid for quality materials. If your contractor breaches any of these rights, you can ask them to redo the work, claim a price reduction, or in serious cases, claim compensation for the cost of getting someone else to fix their mistakes. The Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 also protects you and overlaps with the Consumer Rights Act in many ways.
Your written contract is your first port of call when problems arise. Read it carefully to understand what both parties agreed to. A good building contract should set out the scope of works in detail, the total price and payment schedule, start and completion dates, what happens if there are delays or disputes, insurance requirements, and warranties or guarantees. If you don’t have a written contract, don’t panic. UK law recognises verbal contracts too, though they’re much harder to prove. You’ll need to rely on emails, text messages, quotes, invoices, and any other written evidence to show what was agreed.
Many Manchester contractors use standard industry contracts like the JCT Building Contract for Home Owner or Occupier. These are good because they’re balanced and well tested legally. If your contractor has written their own contract, get it checked by a solicitor before you sign. Some contractors try to include unfair terms that limit your rights or make it hard to hold them accountable. Understanding your contract helps you know when the contractor is actually in breach rather than just doing something you don’t like.
Here’s what to do when things start going wrong with your Manchester main contractor.
The moment you notice a problem, start documenting it. Take detailed photos and videos showing the issue from multiple angles. Write down dates, times, and exactly what happened. If workers didn’t turn up, note it. If work is poor quality, photograph it. If materials are wrong, take pictures with date stamps. Keep every email, text message, letter, and invoice. These records are gold dust if you end up in a dispute. Many homeowners lose claims because they can’t prove what actually happened.
Talk to your contractor as soon as possible, but always follow up in writing. Send an email or letter explaining the problem clearly, what you expect them to do about it, and a reasonable deadline for them to respond. Keep the tone professional and factual rather than emotional or aggressive. This written record shows you tried to resolve things amicably. If they don’t respond or refuse to fix the problem, you’ve got evidence that you gave them a chance. Keep copies of everything you send.
For serious quality or safety issues, pay for an independent surveyor or building inspector to assess the work and write a report. This typically costs £300 to £800 depending on the complexity, but it’s worth every penny. An expert report carries weight if you need to take legal action or make an insurance claim. It proves objectively that the work is substandard rather than just being your word against the contractor’s. Choose someone with proper qualifications like RICS membership.
If the work is seriously deficient or the contractor has breached the contract, you might be within your rights to withhold payment. But be very careful here. Only withhold money that relates directly to the defective work, not the entire amount. Put the money aside so you can pay it if ordered to by a court. Always take legal advice before stopping payment because if you get it wrong, you could be in breach of contract yourself. Never withhold payment as a bargaining chip or out of spite.
Before jumping to legal action, see if you can resolve things through discussion. Offer to meet the contractor on site to go through the issues. Sometimes problems arise from simple misunderstandings rather than deliberate wrongdoing. Suggest bringing in a third party like your architect or a surveyor to mediate. Many contractors will fix problems when they’re clearly explained, especially if you’ve been reasonable and professional. Going straight to lawyers or courts should be a last resort because it’s expensive and time consuming for everyone.
Check if your contractor is registered with any trade bodies or warranty schemes. The Federation of Master Builders, TrustMark, or Checkatrade often have dispute resolution services. If your contractor is a member, lodge a complaint through their scheme. Some schemes offer insurance-backed warranties that can pay for remedial work if the contractor goes bust or refuses to fix problems. This is often quicker and cheaper than going to court.
If informal resolution fails, you have several legal routes. For disputes under £10,000, you can use the Small Claims Court, which is relatively cheap and doesn’t require solicitors. For larger disputes, you might need to go to County Court, which is more formal and expensive. Some contracts include arbitration or adjudication clauses that require disputes to be resolved outside court. These can be quicker but still costly. Always get legal advice before starting any formal proceedings.
Work out exactly what the contractor’s failure has cost you. This might include the cost to fix defective work, the difference between what you paid and what you actually got, additional costs like temporary accommodation if the project overran, loss of rental income if it’s a buy-to-let, and the cost of hiring another contractor to finish the job. Keep receipts and evidence for everything. Courts and arbitrators will want to see proof of your losses, not just estimates.
Before taking legal action, send a formal letter before action. This must follow the Pre-Action Protocol for Construction and Engineering Disputes. The letter should clearly set out what went wrong, what your losses are, what you want the contractor to do, and a deadline for them to respond. Give them a reasonable time, usually 14 to 28 days. This letter shows you followed proper procedure, which courts look favourably on. Many disputes settle at this stage because contractors realise you’re serious.
Sometimes the best option is to cut your losses, get the contractor off site, and hire someone else to finish or fix the work. This is especially true if the contractor is clearly incompetent, has run out of money, or the relationship has completely broken down. Yes, it might cost you more in the short term, but it gets the project finished and reduces your stress. You can still pursue the original contractor for your losses later through legal means.
This is one of the worst situations because you’re left with an unfinished project and may have lost thousands in deposits or stage payments. First, check if the contractor had any insurance-backed warranties or guarantees. Some schemes will pay out to cover the cost of completion or remedial work. Contact any trade bodies they were members of to see if there’s a compensation fund. Check if they were operating as a limited company. If so, you might be able to claim as a creditor in their insolvency, though you’re unlikely to get much back.
Consider whether you have any legal recourse against the company directors personally. In some cases, directors can be held liable if they were trading while insolvent or committed fraud. This requires serious legal advice. For the immediate term, you need to secure the site, protect any materials you’ve already paid for, and get quotes from other contractors to complete the work. Your insurance might cover some costs under your home insurance policy, so check with your insurer.
Prevention is always better than cure. The best protection against contractor problems is doing your homework before you hire. Always get at least three detailed written quotes. Check the contractor is properly registered with HMRC and Companies House. Ask for proof of public liability insurance and employers’ liability insurance. Get references and actually contact them. Visit completed projects if possible. Never pay large amounts upfront. A reasonable deposit is 10 to 20 percent, with the rest paid in stages as work completes.
Make sure you have a detailed written contract before any work starts. Include a schedule of works, detailed costings, payment terms, timelines, and what happens if things go wrong. Build in retention, which means holding back 5 to 10 percent of the final payment for a few months after completion to make sure everything is done properly. Use an architect or project manager if your budget allows. They can oversee the contractor and catch problems early. Dream Homes Construction is known for its reliable, highly skilled tradespeople and its full-service approach, covering design, build and completion. Every project is covered by public liability insurance and a works warranty for total peace of mind.
You should consider hiring a solicitor if the dispute involves more than £10,000, the contractor is threatening legal action against you, the issues are complex or technical, you need to enforce a contract or claim damages, or the contractor has gone bust and you need to navigate insolvency law. Construction solicitors in Manchester typically charge £150 to £350 per hour, so legal fees can add up quickly. Some offer fixed-fee services for straightforward matters like sending letters before action or reviewing contracts.
Before instructing a solicitor, get a clear quote in writing and ask about the realistic prospects of success. There’s no point spending £5,000 in legal fees to recover £3,000. Some solicitors offer no-win-no-fee arrangements for construction disputes, though these usually involve taking a percentage of any compensation you win. Legal expenses insurance might cover your solicitor fees if you have it as part of your home insurance, so check your policy.
Going to court should be your last option because it’s expensive, stressful, and time consuming. Alternative dispute resolution methods are often better. Mediation involves both parties meeting with a neutral mediator who helps you reach a voluntary settlement. It’s typically quicker and cheaper than court and has a high success rate. Sessions cost around £150 to £300 per hour split between both parties. Adjudication is more formal and involves an adjudicator making a binding decision. It’s faster than court but still costs several thousand pounds.
Arbitration is similar to court but private, with an arbitrator making a final binding decision. Some construction contracts require you to use arbitration rather than going to court. These methods work well when both parties are willing to engage. If the contractor refuses to take part or ignores the process, you’ll end up in court anyway. But trying alternative dispute resolution first shows good faith and can reduce your legal costs if you do end up in court.
